The Drawbacks of Prophecy in Guiding Mankind, A Critique of Islamic Doctrine of Prophethood
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21580/teo.2022.33.1.11735Keywords:
Prophecy, Prophets, God, Miracle, Guidance.Abstract
The belief in the prophethood and sending prophets by God to guide mankind is one of the common beliefs of divine religions. According to Islamic theologians, divine knowledge and wisdom necessitate the sending of prophets to guide mankind. This study aims to determine the logical challenges associated with this idea, and whether such a thing is expected from God taking into account His attributes. The drawbacks and challenges of prophecy in the guidance of mankind include the logical problem of miracles' indication of prophecy, the inconsistency of miracles with the claims of prophecy, the temporal and linguistic mismatch between prophets and humans, human fallibility, the prophet's interregnum in the world, the problem of exegesis of the scriptures, and the problem of multiplicity of religions and sects. On the contrary, it appears that All-wise God could have used better, simpler, and more effective ways to guide mankind, such as spiritual and instinctive guidance, direct guidance, the sending of a single eternal prophet, and angelic guidance. As a result of the numerous logical and practical flaws in the use of prophecy to guide mankind, the author believes that it seems unlikely and unacceptable that All-wise and All-knowing God has sent prophets for human guidance, and that another justification must be sought for prophecy.References
Abu al-Ḥasan Ḥalabī. (1414 AH/1993). ʾIshārat al-Sabaq. Qum: Al-Nashr al-Islami institute, first edition.
Abu al-Ḥasan Māwirdī. (1409 AH/1988). ʾAʿlām al-Nubuwwa. Maktabatu al-Hilāl, first edition.
Abu al-Ḥasan Shaʿrānī. (n.d.). Sharḥ Fārsī Tajrīd al-ʾIʿtiqād. Tehran: Intishārāt Islāmīyyah.
ʿAllama Ḥillī. (1363 SH/1984). ʿAnwār al-Malakūt fī Sharḥ al-Yāqūt. Editor: Muḥammad Najmī Zanjānī. Qum: Al-Sharīf Raḍī, second edition.
Āmidī, Sayf Al-Din. (1423 AH/2002). Abkār Al-Afkār fī ʾŪsūl Al-Dīn. Aḥmad Muḥammad Mihdī. Qahira: Dar al-Kutub.
Atrak, Ḥossein. (2018). “A Study and Critique of the «Tark-i Awlà» Approach in Justifying Prophets' Lapses.” The Journal of Philosophical -Theological Research (JPTR), 20 (2), No.76: 29-56. DOI: 10.22091/PFK.2018.2061.1641
Atrak, Ḥossein. (2020 a). Philosophy of Religion Research, 18 (1), No. 35: 217-239.
Atrak, Ḥossein. (2020 b). “A Critical Studying of Implying the Verse “Aṭīʿū” on Infallibility,” Hekmat e Mo‘āṣer, 11 (1): 1-20. DOI. 10.30465/cw.2020.5333.
Atrak, Ḥossein. (2021). “A Critical Survey of the Implication of the Verse ‘Lā Yanāl’ on the Prophets’ Infallibility”. Philosophical Meditations, 11 (1), No. 26: 193-222.
Bājūrī, Ibrāhīm. (1431/2010). Ḥāshīyat-u al-ʾImām Biyjūrī ʿAlā Juharihi al-Tuḥīd. Qāhira: Dār al-.
Fāḍil Miqdād (1422 AH/2001). Al-Lawāmiʿ-u al-Ilāhīyya fi al-Mabāhith-i al-Kalāmīyya. Qom: Daftar Tabliqāt Islami, second edition.
Fāḍil Miqdād. (1412 AH/1991). Al-ʾIʿtimād fī Sharḥ Wājib al-ʾIʿtiqād. Editor: Ḍīyāʾal-Dīn Baṣrī. Mashhad: Majmaʿ al-Būḥūth al-Islāmiyya, first edition.
Fāḍil Miqdād. (1420 AH/1999). Al-ʾAnwār al-Jalālīyya fī Sharḥ al-Fuṣūl al-Naṣīrīyya. Editors: ʿAlī Ḥājī Ābādī & ʿAbbās Jalālī nīyā. Mashhad: Majmaʿ al-Būḥūth al-Islāmiyya, first edition.
Ibn Tīmīyyih. (1425 AH/2004). Sharḥ al-ʿAqīdat al-Isfahanīyyah. Biyrūt: Al-Maktabat al-ʿAṣrīyyah, first edition.
ʾIjī, ʿAḍud Al-Dīn; Jurjānī, Ali ibn Muhammad. (1325 AH/1907). Sharḥ Al-Mawāqif. Editor: Badru al-Dīn Naʿṣānī. Ufsit Qum: Al-Sharīf Raḍī, first edition.
Juwiynī, ʿAbdu al-Malik. (1416 AH/1995). Al-ʾIrshād ʾilā Qawāṭiʿ al-ʾAdillat fī ʾAwwal al-ʾItiqād. Beyrut: Dār al-Kutub al-ʾIlmiyya, first edition.
Makārim Shīrāzī, Nāser. (1379 SH/2000). Al-Amthal fi Tafsīr-i Kītāb-i Al-Munzal. Qum: Madrasah Imam ῾Alī Ibn Abītālib, first edition.
Muʾayyidī, Ibrāhīm ibn Muhammad ibn Aḥmad. (1422 AH/2001). Al-ʾIṣbāḥ ʿala Al-Miṣbāḥ fī Maʿrifat al-Malik al_Fattāḥ. Ṣanʿā: al-Imām Ziyd ibn ʿAlī Institute.
Muḥaqiq Baḥrānī, Ibn Miytham. (1406 AH/1985). Qawāʿid al-Marām fī ʿIlm al-Kalām. Editor; Sayyid Aḥmad Ḥussiynī. Qum: Āyatu Allah Marʿashī Najfī’s Library, second edition.
Musawī, Abd-u al-Rahīm. (1426 AH/2005). Al-Iṣmat-u fi al-Nabuwwat wa al-Imāmat. In: Fī Riḥāb-i Ahl-u al-Bayt, al-Majmaʿ al-Ālāmi li Ahl al-Bayt, vol. 40, second edition.
Muẓaffar, Muḥammad Husiyn (1377 SH). Dalāʾil Al-Ṣidq. Translation: Muhammad Sipihrī. Tehran: Amir Kabīr Press, first edition.
Narāqī, Mulla mahdī. (1369 SH/1990). ʾAnīs al-Muwaḥidīn. Editor: Āyat Allah Qāḍī. Tehran: al-Zahrā, second edition.
Qāḍi ͑Ayāḍ (1407 AH/1986). Al-Shifā bi Ta͑rīf-i Huqūq-u al-Mustafā. ʿAmmān: Dār-u al-Fihā, second edition.
Qāsim ibn Muḥammad ibn ʿAlī. (1421 AH/2000). Al-ʾAsās Liʿaqāid al-ʾAkyās. Ṣaʿda: Maktabt al-Turāth al-Islamī, third edition.
Rāzī Ḥanafī, Abūbakr Aḥmad. (1422 AH/2001). Sharh-u Bidaʾ-u Al-ʾAmālī. Beirut: Dār al-Kutub al-Ilmīyya, first edition.
Rāzī, Fakhr-u al-Dīn. (1420 AH/1999). Tafsīr-u Mafātīh-i al-Ghayb. Beirut: Dār Ihyāʼ al-Turāth al-ʿArabi, third edition.
Rāzī, Fakhr-u al-Dīn. (1986). Al-ʾArbaʿīn fī ʾUsūl al-Dīn. Qāhira: Maktabat al-Kulliyyat al-Azhariyya, first edition.
Sabziwārī, Quṭbu al-Dīn. (1373 SH/1994). Al-Khulāṣat fī ʿIlm al-Kalām. Editor: Rasūl Jaʿfarīyyān. Qum: Āyatu Allah Marʿashī Najfī’s Library, first edition.
Saqqāf, Ḥasan ibn ʿAlī. (1428/2007). Sharḥ Al-ʿAqīdat-u Al-Ṭaḥāwīyya. Biyrūt: Dār al-ʾImām al-Rawās.
Sayyid Murtaḍā (1250 SH/1871), Tanzīh-u al-Anbīyā. Qom: al-Sharīf al- Rāzī.
Sharīf Murtaḍā. (1411 AH/1990). Al-Dhakhīra fī ʿIlm al-Kalām. Editor: Sayyid Aḥmad Ḥussiynī. Qum: al-Nashr al-Islami institute.
Subḥānī, Jaʿfar. (1368 SH/1989). Al-ʾIqidat-u Al-ʾIslāmiyya. Qum: Daftar Tablīghāt Islamī, third edition.
Subḥānī, Jaʿfar. (1381 SH/2002). Al-ʾInṣāf fī Masāʾil Dāma fīha Al-Khilāf. Qum: Muʾasisyi Imam Ṣādiq.
Subḥānī, Jaʿfar. (n.d.). Silsilatu Al-Masāʾil Al-ʿAqāʾidiyya. Qum: Muʾasisyi Imam Ṣādiq.
Ṭabarsī, Faḍl ibn Ḥasan. (1408/1987). Majmaʿ Al-Bayān. Biyrūt: Dār al-Maʿrifat.
Ṭabāṭabāʾī. Muḥammad Ḥussiyn. (1378 SH/1999). Tafsīr Al-Mīzān. Translated by: Muḥammad Bāir Mūsawī. Qum: Daftar Intishārāt Islāmī.
Taftāzānī, Saʿd al-Dīn. (1409 AH/1988), Sharḥ-u Al-Maqāṣid. Qom: al-Sharīf al-Rāzī, first edition.
Tusī, Khāji Naṣīr al-Dīn. (1405 AH/1984). Rasāʾil Khāji Naṣīr Al-Dīn Ṭusī. Beyrut: Dār al-ʾAḍwāʾ, second edition.
Tusī, Khāji Naṣīr al-Dīn. (1407 AH/1986). Tajrīd Al-ʾIʿtiqād. Editor: Ḥusiynī Jalālī. Qum: Daftar Tablīghāt Islamī, first edition.
Ṭusī, Nasīr al-Dīn. (1405 AH/1984). Talkhīṣ al-Muhaṣṣal. Beirūt: Dār al-Aḍwā‘, second edition.
Downloads
Additional Files
Published
Issue
Section
License
The copyright of the received article shall be assigned to the journal as the publisher. The intended copyright includes the right to publish the article in various forms (including reprints). The journal maintains the publishing rights to the published articles.
Note: Authors are allowed to use their articles for any legal purposes deemed necessary without written permission.
Licensing
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
_______
Copyright Transfer Aggreement
In order for Jurnal Theologia to publish and distribute research articles, the editors need publishing rights (transferred from author to publisher). This agreement relates to the transfer/publishing copyright license to Jurnal Theologia but the authors still have significant rights to use and share their published articles.
Jurnal Theologia supports the need for writers to share, disseminate and maximize the impact of their research and their rights on any database. As a journal article writer, you have the right to various uses of your articles, including that by the institution or company where you work. Copyright can be used without the need for special permission. Authors who publish articles in the Jurnal Theologia have broad rights to use their work for teaching and scientific purposes without requesting permission, including:
- Use by the author for lectures, presentations, or conferences, with distribution of copies to participants;
- Distribution to colleagues for research use;
- Use in compilations of the author's subsequent work;
- inclusion in a thesis or dissertation;
- Reuse of sections or excerpts from articles in other works (with full acknowledgment of the final article);
- Preparation of derivative works (other than commercial purposes) (with full acknowledgment of the final article);
- Voluntary posting on open websites operated by authors’ or writers' agencies for scientific purposes
When submitting a manuscript, authors do so on the understanding that if accepted for publication, the copyright for publishing (publishing right) of the article shall be assigned/transferred to Jurnal Theologia.
Authors whose articles are accepted for publication will receive confirmation via email and sent a Copyright Transfer Agreement.
