Peer Review Process Policy
Journal of Integrated Elementary Education (JIEEd) uses a fair, independent, confidential peer-review process to evaluate submissions on scholarly merit, originality, rigor, and relevance to elementary education.
Peer Review Model
Editorial Workflow
- Submission: complete manuscript and metadata are uploaded through OJS.
- Initial screening: scope, article type, technical requirements, originality, ethics, and overall scholarly suitability are checked.
- Review: independent experts evaluate the research question, theory, methods, evidence, interpretation, and contribution.
- Revision: authors provide a revised manuscript and point-by-point response when invited.
- Decision and production: an authorized editor makes the final evidence-based decision; accepted work proceeds to copyediting and publication.
Integrity and Independence
Reviewers must preserve confidentiality and disclose competing interests. Editors handle conflicting reports fairly, may request additional assessment, and retain responsibility for the final decision. Editorial decisions are not influenced by author fees or inappropriate personal, institutional, or financial considerations.